NIL Network

Home NIL Network Insights

NIL Network Insights

    Dear Everyone, Please Stop Calling Donor-Funded Collective Payments “NIL” Before diving into this, I want to make one point abundantly clear: I wholeheartedly believe that revenue-generating college athletes should be paid and paid well. And the free market clearly agrees.Over the past two years, we’ve seen numerous groups, known as “collectives”, emerge with the primary goal of compensating top athletes at their respective universities under the guise of “NIL”. This trend has proven a truth that the NCAA has relentlessly tried to downplay for decades: many college athletes have a market value that far exceeds their scholarship.These collectives are typically founded and led by prominent supporters of the university and primarily pay their athletes using funds raised through donations. Now, if you know the NCAA’s history with boosters, you likely find how this has all played out as amusing as I do.For decades and despite the NCAA’s rules, boosters have been compensating college athletes under the table. A McDonald’s bag full of cash here. A car delivered to an auntie over there.  Most organizations would recognize this recurring issue as an indicator that there was a misalignment between current compensation (scholarship) and actual market value. Most organizations would look at their inability to successfully enforce their rules as a sign to modernize their business model and develop a compensation model that aligns more closely with market value. But not the NCAA. They doubled down. Tripled down. Quadrupled down. The NCAA has spent the last 40+ years doing everything in their power, including spending hundreds of millions of dollars lobbying our government, to not have to compensate any athletes beyond their scholarship.  Now, in the era of NIL, the very group that the NCAA has struggled to regulate for decades are the ones founding and running most of these collectives. Boosters are more empowered than ever, and the NCAA hasn’t really been able to do anything about it. Oh, if this isn’t the consequences of the NCAA’s own (in)actions.But I digress. This isn’t an article about all of that. What I want to address is how labeling these donor-funded collective payments as “NIL” (and including them in NIL valuations) is having a negative impact on the commercial NIL market, resulting in less opportunities for athletes, schools starting to cut NIL resources, and is overall leading us down a road where NIL may be nothing more than retention payments for revenue-generating athletes and national brands partnering with high-profile influencer athletes.The Value of NIL Brand PartnershipsMaybe I’ve drunk the NIL koolaid. Perhaps surrounding myself with NIL advocates, aka the admins and service providers who really believe in this, has created an echo chamber of sorts. But man, do I really believe that it’s going to be a damn shame if a real commercial NIL market never develops the way I believe it could and should. First and foremost, athletes who engage in commercial NIL partnerships gain more than just monetary compensation. They develop professional skills, expand their networks, enhance their resumes, and experience personal growth. Depending on their …

  • Impact of NIL Beyond the Deals: An Unprecedented Growth Opportunity for Women’s Sports  The impact that NIL reform will ultimately have will extend beyond the deals. Way beyond.For the first …

  • NIL PROGRAM COMPARISON Exploring NIL Resources From Leading Universities Disclaimer: Analysis of the NIL programs was conducted through researching the athletic department’s website and reviewing their partner’s press releases. This article is …

As NIL grows rapidly and enters 2024 as a billion dollar industry, more brands are jumping in and reaping the benefits of college athletes promoting their products or services. Unfortunately, there is a misconception that only the biggest and most popular athletes can deliver campaign results. Here, College Athlete Influencers explores why that’s not the case and how brands can maximize their ROI through college athlete influencers.

Join NIL Network

NIL support & guidance, available when you need it.

Our membership is conducive to both the professionals that work in NIL every day and those who just need to keep a pulse on the ever-evolving landscape.


for one year of access

 (limited availability)